Mappa have no excuse

Offline

Dec 2020

128

ManyMaria111 said:
first of all if they didnt pick it up either it would be delayed or it would get picked by a trash studio. And also the trailer wasnt made from mappa

All other studios said no except for mappa.
Delayed better than what we saw. This is just the beginning.

OH yeah? so who did the trailer? SHAME on them if they asked another studio to do it.

Jan 18, 2021 3:16 PM

#4

JustinYeager

Offline

Oct 2016

36

Jehad321 said:
For those who say "blame the production committee, Mappa asked for more time but they got a no no"
Well they should have said no for AOT because, they knew they had a busy and tight schedule and before they pick it up, they have been given a deadline by the production committee. So no excuses for them, other studios said no.

They even did not show us the cgi titnas not in the trailer or in any preview, IF it was good why hide it?

guess if you want deen to make aot, then mappa shouldnt have taken it....

Jan 18, 2021 3:19 PM

#5

furrTrickshot

Offline

Oct 2020

108

They picked up the project before the pandemic and thought they had enough time to do it. But yeah, the pandemic happened. While every other anime title got moved, Attack on Titan for some reason still aired December 2020. This is really the fault of the production committee.

Jan 18, 2021 3:19 PM

#6

_maruwu_

Offline

Jul 2019

202

Jehad321 said:

ManyMaria111 said:
first of all if they didnt pick it up either it would be delayed or it would get picked by a trash studio. And also the trailer wasnt made from mappa

All other studios said no except for mappa.
Delayed better than what we saw. This is just the beginning.

OH yeah? so who did the trailer? SHAME on them if they asked another studio to do it.

bruuuh dont u understand??? if it were delayed the popularity would plummet like it did with s2 nobody would want that. They prob had else do the trailer for them so they have more time to animate the series dumass. Also its only the 1% bitching about this. Most enjoy this and bc there is cgi doesnt mean its bad. And also u can just not watch it if u dont like it -_-

Jan 18, 2021 3:19 PM

#7

Offline

Feb 2019

465

The animation isn't as good as WIT Studio that's for sure, that being said, it's still quite decent but the overuse of CGI does get ugly and now they are using it on humans as well, this was bad.

While I find the CGI decent for the most part I won't praise the animation of the CGI, I will however praise the choreography on the fight scenes which are still quite good, they aren't on WIT Studio level of awesomeness but they are still decent. I give WIT Studio a 10/10 when it comes to choreography, direction, animation in the fight scenes, OST, etc... but I give MAPPA Studio a 8/10 or 8.5/10 so far in those aspects on this season.

The downgrade is definitely there with MAPPA Studio but is not enough to ruin this anime for me...yet, the one that got ruined completely was One Punch Man S02, that one was ugly in terms of choreography and direction and even SFX.

Still, a rating above 9+ is way too freaking high for this season so while I like this season so far I will also call it the most overrated season of the year. At least I'm enjoying this season a lot more than Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood because that one sure is garbage.

Jan 18, 2021 3:29 PM

#8

Offline

Dec 2020

128

ManyMaria111 said:

Jehad321 said:

All other studios said no except for mappa.
Delayed better than what we saw. This is just the beginning.

OH yeah? so who did the trailer? SHAME on them if they asked another studio to do it.

bruuuh dont u understand??? if it were delayed the popularity would plummet like it did with s2 nobody would want that. They prob had else do the trailer for them so they have more time to animate the series dumass. Also its only the 1% bitching about this. Most enjoy this and bc there is cgi doesnt mean its bad. And also u can just not watch it if u dont like it -_-

So u r not sure if they did it or not. I never heard of a studio makes others do the trailer for them. So MAPPA made the trailer titans good then in the anime bad. Its should be the opposite most of the time the anime looks better than the trailer as you know.

What you said is childish exactly like who says "if u didnt like the animation how about u do it ur self"

Jan 18, 2021 3:32 PM

#9

Offline

Dec 2020

128

JustinYeager said:

Jehad321 said:
For those who say "blame the production committee, Mappa asked for more time but they got a no no"
Well they should have said no for AOT because, they knew they had a busy and tight schedule and before they pick it up, they have been given a deadline by the production committee. So no excuses for them, other studios said no.

They even did not show us the cgi titnas not in the trailer or in any preview, IF it was good why hide it?

guess if you want deen to make aot, then mappa shouldnt have taken it....

You make me feel like there is only deen and mappa. Man other studios would have pick it up, but just not this year

Jan 18, 2021 3:34 PM

#10

cloud8100

Offline

Feb 2010

440

Jehad321 said:
For those who say "blame the production committee, Mappa asked for more time but they got a no no"
Well they should have said no for AOT because, they knew they had a busy and tight schedule and before they pick it up, they have been given a deadline by the production committee. So no excuses for them, other studios said no.

They even did not show us the cgi titnas not in the trailer or in any preview, IF it was good why hide it?

You should've just added this to another post instead of starting a new topic.

Jan 18, 2021 3:35 PM

#11

Andigowho

Offline

Aug 2020

110

Can we stop with these cancerous threads?

Jan 18, 2021 3:44 PM

#12

JustinYeager

Offline

Oct 2016

36

Jehad321 said:

JustinYeager said:

guess if you want deen to make aot, then mappa shouldnt have taken it....

You make me feel like there is only deen and mappa. Man other studios would have pick it up, but just not this year

Bro the production comitee wanted to release it before the manga ends to promote it.

If nobody wouldve taken it some bad studio wouldve taken it and makes the adaptation bad or nobody would take it and we might have no s4

Jan 18, 2021 3:47 PM

#13

ArthurBragg

Offline

Dec 2020

106

ManyMaria111 said:
first of all if they didnt pick it up either it would be delayed or it would get picked by a trash studio. And also the trailer wasnt made from mappa. Mikasa and levi look trash???? they are identical to the manga soooo idk what to say. U here for the story or the art style???

i was so appalled by the episode i decided to read the manga and they do not look like their manga counterparts

Jan 18, 2021 3:48 PM

#14

Offline

Dec 2020

128

Resus-2 said:
The animation isn't as good as WIT Studio that's for sure, that being said, it's still quite decent but the overuse of CGI does get ugly and now they are using it on humans as well, this was bad.

While I find the CGI decent for the most part I won't praise the animation of the CGI, I will however praise the choreography on the fight scenes which are still quite good, they aren't on WIT Studio level of awesomeness but they are still decent. I give WIT Studio a 10/10 when it comes to choreography, direction, animation in the fight scenes, OST, etc... but I give MAPPA Studio a 8/10 or 8.5/10 so far in those aspects on this season.

The downgrade is definitely there with MAPPA Studio but is not enough to ruin this anime for me...yet, the one that got ruined completely was One Punch Man S02, that one was ugly in terms of choreography and direction and even SFX.

Still, a rating above 9+ is way too freaking high for this season so while I like this season so far I will also call it the most overrated season of the year. At least I'm enjoying this season a lot more than Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood because that one sure is garbage.

What makes me more worried that mappa only win card right now is the entrance of our favourite characters. So once we get use to them being around I dont think mappa can keep us hyped and entertained in fight senses.

The rating will drop just wait for it

Jan 18, 2021 3:52 PM

#15

HoodKublaiKhan

Offline

Jun 2020

3747

So what should they have done? Not picked it up? Then there'd be no season 4. I'm happy with what I have and if you're not you can always just drop

Jan 18, 2021 3:55 PM

#16

Offline

Dec 2020

128

JustinYeager said:

Jehad321 said:

You make me feel like there is only deen and mappa. Man other studios would have pick it up, but just not this year

Bro the production comitee wanted to release it before the manga ends to promote it.

If nobody wouldve taken it some bad studio wouldve taken it and makes the adaptation bad or nobody would take it and we might have no s4

Man come on its AOT, studios will take it properly wit will start working on it and deliver it by the end of 2021

Jan 18, 2021 3:56 PM

#17

Offline

Feb 2019

465

Jehad321 said:
What makes me more worried that mappa only win card right now is the entrance of our favourite characters. So once we get use to them being around I dont think mappa can keep us hyped and entertained in fight senses.

The rating will drop just wait for it

I definitely want the rating to drop, this season should be around 8 or 8.5, no more than that, this season is overhyped way out of proportions.

I believe MAPPA Studio will actually do better when the action scenes are over because people won't have an excuse to complain about the bad CGI anymore, the story is still decent this season.

Jan 18, 2021 3:58 PM

#18

JustinYeager

Offline

Oct 2016

36

Jehad321 said:

JustinYeager said:

Bro the production comitee wanted to release it before the manga ends to promote it.

If nobody wouldve taken it some bad studio wouldve taken it and makes the adaptation bad or nobody would take it and we might have no s4

Man come on its AOT, studios will take it properly wit will start working on it and deliver it by the end of 2021

Wit dropped the fucking anime because they knew they couldnt adapt it in time so it shows that even wit couldnt do it and probably had to use CGI and we know how bad WIT's CGI was

Jan 18, 2021 4:00 PM

#19

Drac0N

Offline

May 2018

39

You're all whining, CGI in AoT Final Season is (most of the time) very good looking, especially in 6th episode.

Jan 18, 2021 4:04 PM

#20

Offline

Dec 2020

128

JustinYeager said:

Jehad321 said:

Man come on its AOT, studios will take it properly wit will start working on it and deliver it by the end of 2021

Wit dropped the fucking anime because they knew they couldnt adapt it in time so it shows that even wit couldnt do it and probably had to use CGI and we know how bad WIT's CGI was

Knowing that you cant do it and say no. Is better than saying yes and making people hyped with an awesome trailer then fuck up.

Wit only did the colossal Titan with cgi so compare it with mappa colossal so just wait for it.

Jan 18, 2021 4:06 PM

#21

Armavel

Offline

Jan 2021

35

Jehad321 said:

ManyMaria111 said:
first of all if they didnt pick it up either it would be delayed or it would get picked by a trash studio. And also the trailer wasnt made from mappa

All other studios said no except for mappa.
Delayed better than what we saw. This is just the beginning.

OH yeah? so who did the trailer? SHAME on them if they asked another studio to do it.

It's not like that other studios said "No". Most likely Mappa was one of first who were offered project after Wit dropped it.

Jan 18, 2021 4:15 PM

#22

Hyrulia

Offline

Oct 2013

362

Imagine Mappa declines finishing the last part of the manga and studio Deen accepts to produce it!!!
The CGI is good, so stop complaining and enjoy the anime.

Jan 18, 2021 4:16 PM

#23

Offline

Dec 2020

1141

Jehad321 said:
For those who say "blame the production committee, Mappa asked for more time but they got a no no"
Well they should have said no for AOT because, they knew they had a busy and tight schedule and before they pick it up, they have been given a deadline by the production committee. So no excuses for them, other studios said no.

They even did not show us the cgi titnas not in the trailer or in any preview, IF it was good why hide it?

the anime would be most likely picked up by deen or jc staff or another trash studio

Attack on Titan ended with chapter 123 and 130/131 is the epilogue

Jan 18, 2021 4:17 PM

#24

Offline

Dec 2020

1141

Drac0N said:
You're all whining, CGI in AoT Final Season is (most of the time) very good looking, especially in 6th episode.

yes look at the warhammer titan vs mikasa fight, its on par with other odm fights in previous seasons but people are blind with their hate

Attack on Titan ended with chapter 123 and 130/131 is the epilogue

Jan 18, 2021 4:19 PM

#25

Offline

Dec 2020

1141

Armavel said:

Jehad321 said:

All other studios said no except for mappa.
Delayed better than what we saw. This is just the beginning.

OH yeah? so who did the trailer? SHAME on them if they asked another studio to do it.

It's not like that other studios said "No". Most likely Mappa was one of first who were offered project after Wit dropped it.

no do a research bro so many studios said no even ufotable or bones

Attack on Titan ended with chapter 123 and 130/131 is the epilogue

Jan 18, 2021 4:27 PM

#26

Offline

Nov 2019

1192

Jehad321 said:
For those who say "blame the production committee, Mappa asked for more time but they got a no no"
Well they should have said no for AOT because, they knew they had a busy and tight schedule and before they pick it up, they have been given a deadline by the production committee. So no excuses for them, other studios said no.

They even did not show us the cgi titnas not in the trailer or in any preview, IF it was good why hide it?

Uh... Because they know how much people hate cg, outside of studio orange and ufotable? Also, Attack on Titan is a huge project. If it was dropped, what do you think would happen? There would be a huge uproar. Ufotable definitely wouldn't have picked it up, and neither would madhouse. The best studio would be studio Mappa, since they have the same founder as the guy who founded madhouse, and has a lot of resources to pull from. That's why the cgi looks better than most cg, because of their contacts in v-sign. Also, they did show scenes of cgi in the trailer. It was just short clips, however. Plus, a trailer won't really have cgi, since why would people be excited about your show then?

Jan 18, 2021 4:28 PM

#27

daft_mariner

Offline

Jul 2020

110

Am I the only one who just doesn't see the problem? Only a couple, short scenes had unnecessary CGI that I may have had a small gripe with. But the fact that in order for me to produce any sort of hate for the episode would be to nitpick those details to extreme levels goes to show how good the episode was, and testament to just how good not only the story is, but the direction and pacing is. There was still some awesome hand-drawn animation, and the CGI was top-notch imo and actually very cleverly used.

I'm an anime-only and I'm having a f*cking BLAST with the season. The idea that 'MAPPA has no excuses' seems so weird to me. At the end of the day, excuse for what? Airing it too early? Ok, so they should be ashamed now? You think Isayama would want us to shame them? Is it really worth it to go out of your way to post a thread like this? It's even worse with tweets that go out of their way to harass a director of the series who didn't even work in the episode. It just goes to show how delusional all of it is.

Besides, who knows if they're saving budget for later episodes?

Jan 18, 2021 4:28 PM

#28

Offline

Nov 2019

1192

Jehad321 said:

ManyMaria111 said:
first of all if they didnt pick it up either it would be delayed or it would get picked by a trash studio. And also the trailer wasnt made from mappa

All other studios said no except for mappa.
Delayed better than what we saw. This is just the beginning.

OH yeah? so who did the trailer? SHAME on them if they asked another studio to do it.

Uh... They did the trailer. It's pre animated, which means they took scenes from the manga, and animated it strictly for this trailer.

Jan 18, 2021 4:35 PM

#29

Offline

Nov 2019

1192

Resus-2 said:
The animation isn't as good as WIT Studio that's for sure, that being said, it's still quite decent but the overuse of CGI does get ugly and now they are using it on humans as well, this was bad.

While I find the CGI decent for the most part I won't praise the animation of the CGI, I will however praise the choreography on the fight scenes which are still quite good, they aren't on WIT Studio level of awesomeness but they are still decent. I give WIT Studio a 10/10 when it comes to choreography, direction, animation in the fight scenes, OST, etc... but I give MAPPA Studio a 8/10 or 8.5/10 so far in those aspects on this season.

The downgrade is definitely there with MAPPA Studio but is not enough to ruin this anime for me...yet, the one that got ruined completely was One Punch Man S02, that one was ugly in terms of choreography and direction and even SFX.

Still, a rating above 9+ is way too freaking high for this season so while I like this season so far I will also call it the most overrated season of the year. At least I'm enjoying this season a lot more than Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood because that one sure is garbage.

Uh... I mean, that's debatable. I've been recently rewatching attack on titan with my friend, who now loves the series, and after watching up to season 4 episode 5, I saw so many problems with the animation with wit. Sure, wit does have higher moments, but they are wildly inconsistent. Like, in episode 4, every character looks fucking wack, and the coloring and shadows were way off. Now, again, this was wit's first project. But compare that to Mappa's first episodes. Yeah, they used CGI, and rotoscopping, but damn does it look good. There hasn't been a single scene in season 4 where I'm like, "What are the animators doing?" I saw that plenty of times with wit, however. But that's to knock wit. They have amazing animation, but they've had a lot more time. Mappa has less high quality animated shots, but the overall animation quality is top tier. The rotoscopping is amazing, and the cgi actually blends decently well, because the Titans are acting more like robots and mecha, rather than organic creatures, because Eren himself isn't rage driven, and isn't treating his titan form as animalistic.

Jan 18, 2021 4:37 PM

#30

Offline

Nov 2019

1192

Jehad321 said:

ManyMaria111 said:

bruuuh dont u understand??? if it were delayed the popularity would plummet like it did with s2 nobody would want that. They prob had else do the trailer for them so they have more time to animate the series dumass. Also its only the 1% bitching about this. Most enjoy this and bc there is cgi doesnt mean its bad. And also u can just not watch it if u dont like it -_-

So u r not sure if they did it or not. I never heard of a studio makes others do the trailer for them. So MAPPA made the trailer titans good then in the anime bad. Its should be the opposite most of the time the anime looks better than the trailer as you know.

What you said is childish exactly like who says "if u didnt like the animation how about u do it ur self"

Why is everyone acting like the anime is unwatchable? It's great. You should watch season 1 episode 4. You'll come to appreciate Mappa. You won't get wack shots like that.

Jan 18, 2021 4:37 PM

#31

Offline

Dec 2020

1141

daft_mariner said:
Am I the only one who just doesn't see the problem? Only a couple, short scenes had unnecessary CGI that I may have had a small gripe with. But the fact that in order for me to produce any sort of hate for the episode would be to nitpick those details to extreme levels goes to show how good the episode was, and testament to just how good not only the story is, but the direction and pacing is. There was still some awesome hand-drawn animation, and the CGI was top-notch imo and actually very cleverly used.

I'm an anime-only and I'm having a f*cking BLAST with the season. The idea that 'MAPPA has no excuses' seems so weird to me. At the end of the day, excuse for what? Airing it too early? Ok, so they should be ashamed now? You think Isayama would want us to shame them? Is it really worth it to go out of your way to post a thread like this? It's even worse with tweets that go out of their way to harass a director of the series who didn't even work in the episode. It just goes to show how delusional all of it is.

Besides, who knows if they're saving budget for later episodes?

the qualiy is really good, you are enjoying it because you dont nitpick every shit

Attack on Titan ended with chapter 123 and 130/131 is the epilogue

Jan 18, 2021 4:40 PM

#32

Mewra

Offline

Mar 2012

384

i didn't mind the cgi at first, i thought the first episode looked great.
but in this last episode we got... oh boy.. it was WAY overused. i honestly don't know why they chose to use so much cgi in this short fight, and the warhammer's design isn't even that complicated compared to other titans. but what bothered me the most is the attack titan's cgi, it didn't look bad in all of the cgi shots but some of them looked like they were from a video game. i'm honestly running out of excuses to defend mappa. i'm trying to be optimistic and think that perhaps they saved all the budget for the rumbling, but i don't wanna get my hopes up.

物事は良くなりますか？

Jan 18, 2021 4:43 PM

#33

Offline

Nov 2019

1192

Jehad321 said:

JustinYeager said:

guess if you want deen to make aot, then mappa shouldnt have taken it....

You make me feel like there is only deen and mappa. Man other studios would have pick it up, but just not this year

Yeah. This year. I don't know if you noticed, but Attack on Titan being delayed would cause an even higher uproar than what's being done now. Wit doesn't have the resources, and, to be completely honest, I don't see any other studio even picking it up. Studio orange is fine with beastars, Wit is doing Vinland saga, David productions is doing JoJo, probably a 3rd season of fire force, and cells at work, ufotable definitely isn't going to pick up attack on titan with the amount they had to animate, madhouse is mostly dead, kyoto animations had their studio burned down, so they probably need more time, etc. Mappa is the only one who even considered doing it, and look what they got in return. Attack on Titan season 4 had one of the largest premieres in anime history, declaration of war made it go from a number 7-8 to number 2 on mal, not to mention, attack on titan is on the trending tab, alongside real world events, even eclipsing real world events in popularity. No other studio even considered it, save for Mappa. Show some respect.

Jan 18, 2021 4:45 PM

#34

Offline

Nov 2019

1192

ArthurBragg said:

ManyMaria111 said:
first of all if they didnt pick it up either it would be delayed or it would get picked by a trash studio. And also the trailer wasnt made from mappa. Mikasa and levi look trash???? they are identical to the manga soooo idk what to say. U here for the story or the art style???

i was so appalled by the episode i decided to read the manga and they do not look like their manga counterparts

I've read the manga. Mikasa looks like her. So does Levi, Eren, Falco, Renier, Porco, etc. Also, Hajime Isayama said the anime is his final form of aot.

Jan 18, 2021 4:46 PM

#35

Offline

Nov 2019

1192

Jehad321 said:

Resus-2 said:
The animation isn't as good as WIT Studio that's for sure, that being said, it's still quite decent but the overuse of CGI does get ugly and now they are using it on humans as well, this was bad.

While I find the CGI decent for the most part I won't praise the animation of the CGI, I will however praise the choreography on the fight scenes which are still quite good, they aren't on WIT Studio level of awesomeness but they are still decent. I give WIT Studio a 10/10 when it comes to choreography, direction, animation in the fight scenes, OST, etc... but I give MAPPA Studio a 8/10 or 8.5/10 so far in those aspects on this season.

The downgrade is definitely there with MAPPA Studio but is not enough to ruin this anime for me...yet, the one that got ruined completely was One Punch Man S02, that one was ugly in terms of choreography and direction and even SFX.

Still, a rating above 9+ is way too freaking high for this season so while I like this season so far I will also call it the most overrated season of the year. At least I'm enjoying this season a lot more than Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood because that one sure is garbage.

What makes me more worried that mappa only win card right now is the entrance of our favourite characters. So once we get use to them being around I dont think mappa can keep us hyped and entertained in fight senses.

The rating will drop just wait for it

I doubt it. Chapter 112 being adapted.

Jan 18, 2021 4:49 PM

#36

Offline

Feb 2019

465

racers551 said:
Uh... I mean, that's debatable. I've been recently rewatching attack on titan with my friend, who now loves the series, and after watching up to season 4 episode 5, I saw so many problems with the animation with wit. Sure, wit does have higher moments, but they are wildly inconsistent. Like, in episode 4, every character looks fucking wack, and the coloring and shadows were way off. Now, again, this was wit's first project. But compare that to Mappa's first episodes. Yeah, they used CGI, and rotoscopping, but damn does it look good. There hasn't been a single scene in season 4 where I'm like, "What are the animators doing?" I saw that plenty of times with wit, however. But that's to knock wit. They have amazing animation, but they've had a lot more time. Mappa has less high quality animated shots, but the overall animation quality is top tier. The rotoscopping is amazing, and the cgi actually blends decently well, because the Titans are acting more like robots and mecha, rather than organic creatures, because Eren himself isn't rage driven, and isn't treating his titan form as animalistic.

Yeah MAPPA Studio is doing a great job so far, they are oversusing the CGI but fortunately that's not ruining this season for me because everything else is great, Wit Studio does have inconsistent ugly scenes in some parts like the 2nd fight of Eren vs Armor Titan, the 1st fight between them was amazing, the 2nd fight between them was horrible though, the animation was ugly, on par with crappy filler episodes from Naruto, it was THAT bad.

That being said, those are the only few rare moments from WIT Studio with ugly animation IMHO, everything else was excellent in that anime and the hype moments were off the roof, the direction, OST and choreography in the hype moments are top tier, on top of the food chain in animes and this is where WIT Studio shines IMHO, I don't think MAPPA Studio can deliever those scenes as good as WIT Studio but so far I'm not complaining with MAPPA Studio, it may not be top tier but they are still doing a great job. I will however complain about the extremely high rating since I don't believe it deserves it yet, I will also complain about the overuse of CGI but like I said, it's not ruining my enjoyment of this season yet.

Jan 18, 2021 4:51 PM

#37

Offline

Nov 2019

1192

Jehad321 said:

JustinYeager said:

Bro the production comitee wanted to release it before the manga ends to promote it.

If nobody wouldve taken it some bad studio wouldve taken it and makes the adaptation bad or nobody would take it and we might have no s4

Man come on its AOT, studios will take it properly wit will start working on it and deliver it by the end of 2021

Which one? Ufotable? They do 2-3 anime per year, tops. They wouldn't want to touch aot. Madhouse? Mostly quiet. Studio orange? They're fine with beastars. Wit? They are focusing on delivering season 2 of Vinland Saga. Seven arcs? Studio deen? JC Staff? Not the best history of adapting anime, or taking on anime from other studios. White fox? They are around the same size as wit, and based on the problems wit had with attack on titan, I can't imagine the problems the same studio that did re:zero would be able to do this well. A-1 pictures? Hit or miss in animation/adaptation. Mappa actually has a pretty damn good record for adapting both original anime and manga. Plus, Jujutsu Kaisen is amazingly animated.

Jan 18, 2021 4:52 PM

#38

Armavel

Offline

Jan 2021

35

racers551 said:

Jehad321 said:

What makes me more worried that mappa only win card right now is the entrance of our favourite characters. So once we get use to them being around I dont think mappa can keep us hyped and entertained in fight senses.

The rating will drop just wait for it

I doubt it. Chapter 112 being adapted.

I think chapter 114 will establish AOT as No1 in ranking. But let's see.

Jan 18, 2021 4:55 PM

#39

Offline

Nov 2019

1192

Resus-2 said:

racers551 said:
Uh... I mean, that's debatable. I've been recently rewatching attack on titan with my friend, who now loves the series, and after watching up to season 4 episode 5, I saw so many problems with the animation with wit. Sure, wit does have higher moments, but they are wildly inconsistent. Like, in episode 4, every character looks fucking wack, and the coloring and shadows were way off. Now, again, this was wit's first project. But compare that to Mappa's first episodes. Yeah, they used CGI, and rotoscopping, but damn does it look good. There hasn't been a single scene in season 4 where I'm like, "What are the animators doing?" I saw that plenty of times with wit, however. But that's to knock wit. They have amazing animation, but they've had a lot more time. Mappa has less high quality animated shots, but the overall animation quality is top tier. The rotoscopping is amazing, and the cgi actually blends decently well, because the Titans are acting more like robots and mecha, rather than organic creatures, because Eren himself isn't rage driven, and isn't treating his titan form as animalistic.

Yeah MAPPA Studio is doing a great job so far, they are oversusing the CGI but fortunately that's not ruining this season for me because everything else is great, Wit Studio does have inconsistent ugly scenes in some parts like the 2nd fight of Eren vs Armor Titan, the 1st fight between them was amazing, the 2nd fight between them was horrible though, the animation was ugly, on par with crappy filler episodes from Naruto, it was THAT bad.

That being said, those are the only few rare moments from WIT Studio with ugly animation IMHO, everything else was excellent in that anime and the hype moments were off the roof, the direction, OST and choreography in the hype moments are top tier, on top of the food chain in animes and this is where WIT Studio shines IMHO, I don't think MAPPA Studio can deliever those scenes as good as WIT Studio but so far I'm not complaining with MAPPA Studio, it may not be top tier but they are still doing a great job. I will however complain about the extremely high rating since I don't believe it deserves it yet, I will also complain about the overuse of CGI but like I said, it's not ruining my enjoyment of this season yet.

I mean, outside of animation, everyone who was on the previous aot committee was also still working on the show. Music, storyboarding, etc, were still done by the same people.

Jan 18, 2021 5:03 PM

#40

Offline

Feb 2019

465

racers551 said:
I mean, outside of animation, everyone who was on the previous aot committee was also still working on the show. Music, storyboarding, etc, were still done by the same people.

That's good to know then, this season is in good hands but damn it, I wish they used less CGI. This is a good season so far, way too overhyped but a good season nonethless.

Jan 18, 2021 5:04 PM

#41

butterflyeffectt

Offline

Sep 2020

2474

They need to delay it after jjk ends tbh,so the main staff can go to aot

ManyMaria111 said:
first of all if they didnt pick it up either it would be delayed or it would get picked by a trash studio. And also the trailer wasnt made from mappa. Mikasa and levi look trash???? they are identical to the manga soooo idk what to say. U here for the story or the art style???

BECAUSE THIS IS 4 YEARS TIME SKIP

butterflyeffecttJan 18, 2021 5:11 PM

Jan 18, 2021 5:06 PM

#42

malrefusestodlt

Offline

Apr 2020

74

ManyMaria111 said:
first of all if they didnt pick it up either it would be delayed or it would get picked by a trash studio. And also the trailer wasnt made from mappa. Mikasa and levi look trash???? they are identical to the manga soooo idk what to say. U here for the story or the art style???

Use the rational part of your brain before posting please. MAPPA accepted it so they aren't blameless either. I'm not watching RWBY, I'm watching AoT.

Jan 18, 2021 5:12 PM

#43

Offline

Feb 2019

465

FesterTY said:
I'm not watching RWBY, I'm watching AoT.

Speaking of RWBY, I do enjoy that american anime... a lot, I like RWBY more than a lot of animes out there, RWBY shines in the choreography of the fight scenes which are pretty darn good IMHO.

Jan 18, 2021 5:25 PM

#44

Offline

Nov 2019

1192

Resus-2 said:

racers551 said:
I mean, outside of animation, everyone who was on the previous aot committee was also still working on the show. Music, storyboarding, etc, were still done by the same people.

That's good to know then, this season is in good hands but damn it, I wish they used less CGI. This is a good season so far, way too overhyped but a good season nonethless.

Oh. It's definitely not way overhyped. It's perfectly hyped, from what I've read in the manga.

Jan 18, 2021 5:34 PM

#45

Offline

Feb 2019

465

racers551 said:
Oh. It's definitely not way overhyped. It's perfectly hyped, from what I've read in the manga.

Well buddy on this one we have to agree to disagree. This is a good season so far but I don't think I've seen enough "excellent material" on this season to deserve a rating of 9+, MAPPA Studio has shown that they have potential to make a great season out of it no doubt but not enough to have a #2 spot from hundred of animes out there, this is what I call overhyped or overrated but I'm not surprised coming from MAL, the #1 spot belongs to FMAB and I've found that anime to be mediocre hot garbage at best so I don't trust the ratings here.

Jan 18, 2021 6:21 PM

#46

Offline

Nov 2019

1192

Resus-2 said:

racers551 said:
Oh. It's definitely not way overhyped. It's perfectly hyped, from what I've read in the manga.

Well buddy on this one we have to agree to disagree. This is a good season so far but I don't think I've seen enough "excellent material" on this season to deserve a rating of 9+, MAPPA Studio has shown that they have potential to make a great season out of it no doubt but not enough to have a #2 spot from hundred of animes out there, this is what I call overhyped or overrated but I'm not surprised coming from MAL, the #1 spot belongs to FMAB and I've found that anime to be mediocre hot garbage at best so I don't trust the ratings here.

Well... The series is going to surpass your expectations. It's turned from fighting an enemy so simple anyone could get behind it, to a series that is so complex that it has divided the manga readers, and everything you have seen in season 1-3 part 2 is just building up to the final episode.

Jan 18, 2021 6:23 PM

#47

shane_nichols

Offline

Jun 2015

1116

Toxoc fanboy. Be happy with what you got or simply fuck off

Jan 18, 2021 6:26 PM

#48

DragonYuk

FMAB is the BEST

Offline

Aug 2017

129

Jehad321 said:
For those who say "blame the production committee, Mappa asked for more time but they got a no no"
Well they should have said no for AOT because, they knew they had a busy and tight schedule and before they pick it up, they have been given a deadline by the production committee. So no excuses for them, other studios said no.

They even did not show us the cgi titnas not in the trailer or in any preview, IF it was good why hide it?

Jesus fuck be happy of what you get or stop watching the fucking show. People like you don't even deserve to watch Anime in general.

Greed has poisoned men’s souls, has barricaded the world with hate, has goose-stepped us into misery and bloodshed.

Jan 18, 2021 6:51 PM

#49

ShadowUnown

Offline

Apr 2015

661

Resus-2 said:
The animation isn't as good as WIT Studio that's for sure, that being said, it's still quite decent but the overuse of CGI does get ugly and now they are using it on humans as well, this was bad.

While I find the CGI decent for the most part I won't praise the animation of the CGI, I will however praise the choreography on the fight scenes which are still quite good, they aren't on WIT Studio level of awesomeness but they are still decent. I give WIT Studio a 10/10 when it comes to choreography, direction, animation in the fight scenes, OST, etc... but I give MAPPA Studio a 8/10 or 8.5/10 so far in those aspects on this season.

The downgrade is definitely there with MAPPA Studio but is not enough to ruin this anime for me...yet, the one that got ruined completely was One Punch Man S02, that one was ugly in terms of choreography and direction and even SFX.

Still, a rating above 9+ is way too freaking high for this season so while I like this season so far I will also call it the most overrated season of the year. At least I'm enjoying this season a lot more than Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood because that one sure is garbage.

You completely ruined all your credibility with your last statement lol Literally any show in the Top 30 is better than Shitgeki no CGI - The Final Crap.

Jan 18, 2021 6:56 PM

#50